A heated family debate unfolded online after the Super Bowl halftime show, as Logan Paul Slams Brother Jake Paul for Claiming Bad Bunny Is a “Fake American Citizen”, pushing back against remarks that quickly ignited backlash across social media.
Logan Paul Breaks Ranks With His Brother
Logan Paul didn’t hold back when responding to comments made by his younger brother, Jake Paul, about six-time Grammy winner Bad Bunny.
Following the Super Bowl halftime performance, Logan publicly distanced himself from Jake’s controversial remarks. Writing on X, Logan made it clear that while he loves his brother, he strongly disagreed with his take.
“I love my brother but I don’t agree with this,” Logan posted.
He went on to emphasize that Puerto Ricans are American citizens and expressed pride in seeing talent from the island represented on such a massive stage. Puerto Rico has been a U.S. territory since 1898, and its residents have been recognized as U.S. citizens since 1917.
Jake Paul’s Controversial Comments
Hours before the halftime show, Jake vowed to tune out the performance, calling on others to do the same. He framed his stance as a protest against corporate influence, encouraging viewers to withhold their viewership.
In his post, Jake described Bad Bunny as a “fake American citizen” and criticized the artist for publicly denouncing U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The comment quickly drew criticism, with many pointing out that Bad Bunny — born Benito Antonio Martínez Ocasio in Puerto Rico — is legally an American citizen.
A community note added context to Jake’s post, clarifying Puerto Rico’s citizenship status and noting that Jake himself has lived in Puerto Rico since 2021.
Political Figures Weigh In
The controversy extended beyond social media influencers. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez publicly criticized Jake, accusing him of benefiting from living in Puerto Rico while questioning the patriotism of others from the island.
She also contrasted his comments with Bad Bunny’s philanthropic efforts, highlighting the artist’s funding of arts and sports programs for low-income youth.
Jake Paul Attempts to Clarify
By Monday morning, Jake began walking back his original remarks. He stated that he wasn’t disputing anyone’s legal citizenship status and reiterated his affection for Puerto Rico.
Instead, Jake reframed his argument, claiming he was using the phrase “fake citizen” metaphorically to criticize public figures who he believes benefit from the U.S. while speaking out against its policies — particularly ICE enforcement actions.
Bad Bunny’s Grammy Moment
Just a week before the Super Bowl, Bad Bunny made headlines at the Grammy Awards, where he won Best Música Urbana Album for “DeBÍ TiRAR MáS FOToS.” During his acceptance speech, he delivered a pointed message: “ICE out.”
He continued by affirming the humanity and identity of Puerto Ricans and other marginalized communities, declaring, “We’re not savage. We’re not animals. We’re not aliens. We are humans, and we are Americans.”
His remarks became part of a larger national debate surrounding immigration, identity, and representation — themes that carried into reactions to his Super Bowl performance.
Alternative Halftime Programming
For viewers who chose not to watch Bad Bunny’s set, an alternative livestream event was hosted by Turning Point USA, featuring a performance by Kid Rock.
The event, which ran longer than the official halftime show at Levi’s Stadium, included musical tributes and conservative commentary.
Reactions From Public Figures
The backlash and support continued to ripple through public discourse. Donald Trump criticized the halftime show on social media, taking issue with the Spanish-language lyrics and calling the performance “terrible.”
Reality TV personality Jill Zarin also shared negative remarks about the show before later deleting her comments.
Meanwhile, pop superstar Lady Gaga appeared prominently during the halftime spectacle, countering claims that the performance lacked diversity.
A Family Feud Reflecting a National Debate
At its core, the dispute between Logan and Jake Paul mirrors a broader national conversation about citizenship, cultural identity, and political expression. While Jake framed his comments as political criticism, Logan’s response focused on unity and recognition of Puerto Rican Americans’ contributions to U.S. culture.
The halftime show may have lasted only minutes, but the online debate that followed continues to spark conversations about patriotism, representation, and the power of public platforms.
